Plata et al. v. The City of San Jose

HearingDescription: Remittitur issued.

DocketDescription: Answer to petition for review received.; Notes: Courtesy copy of answer by City of San Jose to petition for review filed in Supreme Court.

DocketDescription: Service copy of petition for review received.; Notes: By pltfs/ Aplts/ petitioners Raymond and Michelle Plata. S273586

DispositionDescription: Affirmed in part and reversed in part; Disposition Type: Final Affirmed in part and reversed in part. Bedsworth Marks Concurring and dissenting. Moore; Publication Status: Signed Published; Author: Bedsworth, William W.; Participants: Marks, Linda S. (Concur) Moore, Eileen C. (Concur with Opinion)

DocketDescription: Opinion filed.; Notes: (Signed Published) Affirmed in part and reversed in part. Bedsworth Marks Concurring and dissenting. Moore

DocketDescription: Cause argued and submitted.; Notes: Merits. Cause called. Matthew Schechter argued for appellants. Kathryn Zoglin argued for respondent. Cause submitted.

DocketDescription: Order filed.; Notes: On the court's own motion and for good cause, the parties are ordered to be prepared to discuss the following issues at oral argument: 1. Whether and to what extent the factual basis for the appellants' claim regarding the San Jose Municipal Water System's (Muni Water's) tiered rate structure was captured in the pre-litigation government claims filed with the City of San Jose, and specifically why or why not; 2. What acts or omissions by the City of San Jose would have been relevant to appellants' Proposition 218 claim as it relates to Muni Water's water rates generally, and how are those acts or omissions identical to, similar to, or different from, the acts or omissions relevant to an analysis of Muni Water's tiered rate structure specifically?Order called in.

DocketDescription: Calendar notice sent electronically. Calendar date:

DocketDescription: Filed letter from:; Notes: Respondent's /cross appellant's notice of unavailability.

DocketDescription: Request for oral argument filed by:; Notes: Atty Matthew Schechter will argue for appellants -30 minutes.

DocketDescription: Civil case information statement filed.; Notes: As to cross- appeal City of San Jose

DocketDescription: Appellant's mediation statement filed.; Notes: As to City of San Jose

DocketDescription: Civil case information statement filed.; Notes: As to Plata et al.

DocketDescription: Appellant's mediation statement filed.; Notes: Appellants' Raymond and Michelle Plata

DocketDescription: Returned document for non-conformance.; Notes: Appellant's Plata et al. missing copy of judgment for civil case information

DocketDescription: Notice of appeal lodged/received.; Notes: Cross appeal City of San Jose, filed 8/17/2018

DocketDescription: Appellant 's notice designating record on appeal filed in trial court on:; Notes: Filed 8/16/2018.

DocketDescription: Default notice sent-appellant notified per rule 8.100(c).

DocketDescription: Notice of appeal lodged/received.; Notes: Appellant Raymond Plata et al., Filed 8/6/2018

DocketTrial Court Name: Santa Clara County Superior Court; County: Santa Clara; Trial Court Case Number: 2014-1-CV-258879; Trial Court Judge: Kuhnle, Thomas