CHRISTOPHER ROMERO ET AL VS BEVERLY SANCHEZ ET AL
Case Summary
On 12/14/2016 CHRISTOPHER ROMERO filed a Personal Injury - Other Personal Injury lawsuit against BEVERLY SANCHEZ. This case was filed in Los Angeles County Superior Courts, Norwalk Courthouse located in Los Angeles, California. The Judges overseeing this case are LAURA A. SEIGLE, AMY D. HOGUE and MARGARET MILLER BERNAL. The case status is Pending - Other Pending.
Case Details
-
Case Number:
****3524
-
Filing Date:
12/14/2016
-
Case Status:
Pending - Other Pending
-
Courthouse:
Norwalk Courthouse
-
County, State:
Los Angeles, California
Judge Details
Presiding Judges
LAURA A. SEIGLE
AMY D. HOGUE
MARGARET MILLER BERNAL
Party Details
Plaintiff
ROMERO CHRISTOPHER
Defendants and Respondents
JARVIS DAVID CLIFFORD
JERVIS DONALD LEROY
JARVIS PINKY
VASQUEZ XIOMARA
ZAKARIA YEHIA
SANCHEZ BEVERLY
DOES 1 THROUGH 5
JARVIS DONALD L.
JERVIS PINKEY
MGTD PROPERTIES LP
CROWNVIC ONE LLC
MARTINEZ ANGEL
Attorney/Law Firm Details
Defendant Attorneys
SAFARIAN AROUTUN HARRY
LEE CHRISTINE S.
Court Documents
5/29/2018: FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT FOR DAMAGES;AND ETC.
9/26/2018: PROOF OF SERVICE SUMMONS
9/26/2018: PROOF OF SERVICE SUMMONS
9/26/2018: PROOF OF SERVICE SUMMONS
9/26/2018: PROOF OF SERVICE SUMMONS
10/26/2018: Declaration
10/26/2018: Motion to Quash Service of Summons
11/30/2018: Unknown
12/6/2018: Unknown
1/11/2019: Minute Order
1/11/2019: Unknown
4/4/2019: Opposition
4/4/2019: Case Management Statement
4/5/2019: Opposition
5/14/2019: Minute Order
5/16/2019: Notice of Ruling
5/24/2019: Other -
12/14/2016: COMPLAINT FO DAMAGES 1. COMPLAINT BY TENANTS AGAINST LANDLORD FOR DAMAGES FOR PERSONAL INJURIES LAND PROPERTY DAMAGEJBASED ON NEGLIGENCE [CIV. CODE 1714(A), 3333]; AND ETC
Docket Entries
- 05/24/2019
-
summons on second amended complaint; Filed by Christopher Romero (Plaintiff)
- 05/24/2019
-
Second Amended Complaint; Filed by Christopher Romero (Plaintiff)
- 05/24/2019
-
Answer; Filed by Xiomara Vasquez (Defendant); Yehia Zakaria (Defendant)
- 05/16/2019
-
Notice of Ruling; Filed by Beverly Sanchez (Defendant); Xiomara Vasquez (Defendant); Yehia Zakaria (Defendant)
- 05/14/2019
-
at 1:30 PM in Department C; Hearing on Motion to Quash Service of Summons - Held - Motion Granted
- 05/14/2019
-
at 1:30 PM in Department C; Hearing on Demurrer - with Motion to Strike (CCP 430.10) - Held
- 05/14/2019
-
at 1:30 PM in Department C; Hearing on Motion to Quash Service of Summons - Held
- 05/14/2019
-
Order (re: hearing of 5/14/19); Filed by Clerk
- 05/14/2019
-
Minute Order ( (Hearing on Demurrer - with Motion to Strike (CCP 430.10); Hea...)); Filed by Clerk
- 04/10/2019
-
at 08:30 AM in Department F, Margaret Miller Bernal, Presiding; Case Management Conference - Held
- 05/30/2018
-
Minute Order
- 05/29/2018
-
Complaint ( (1st)); Filed by Christopher Romero (Plaintiff)
- 05/29/2018
-
FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT FOR DAMAGES;AND ETC.
- 05/29/2018
-
First Amended Complaint; Filed by Christopher Romero (Plaintiff)
- 08/16/2017
-
Notice of Change of Address or Other Contact Information; Filed by Christopher Romero (Plaintiff)
- 08/16/2017
-
NOTICE OF CHANGE OF ADDRESS OR OTHER CONTACT INFORMATION
- 12/14/2016
-
COMPLAINT FO DAMAGES 1. COMPLAINT BY TENANTS AGAINST LANDLORD FOR DAMAGES FOR PERSONAL INJURIES LAND PROPERTY DAMAGEJBASED ON NEGLIGENCE [CIV. CODE 1714(A), 3333]; AND ETC
- 12/14/2016
-
Complaint; Filed by Christopher Romero (Plaintiff)
- 12/14/2016
-
ORDER ON COURT FEE WAIVER
- 12/14/2016
-
SUMMONS
Tentative Rulings
Case Number: BC643524 Hearing Date: January 07, 2020 Dept: SEC
ROMERO v. SANCHEZ, et al.
CASE NO.: BC643524
HEARING: 1/7/19
JUDGE: OLIVIA ROSALES
#6
TENTATIVE ORDER
I. Defendant Sanchez’s demurrer is SUSTAINED without leave to amend.
II. Defendants Sanchez, Vasquez, and Zakaria’s motion to strike is DENIED.
Moving parties to give NOTICE.
I. Demurrer
Defendant Sanchez demurs to the 1st – 2nd causes of action on the grounds that they fail to state facts sufficient to constitute causes of action and are uncertain.
UNCERTAINTY
Demurrer on grounds of uncertainty will not be sustained unless the complaint is so bad that the defendant cannot reasonably respond. (Koury v. Maly’s of California (1993) 14 Cal.App.4th 612, 616.)
On 5/14/19, this court found that the First Amended Complaint was uncertain as to Beverly Sanchez because the FAC alleged no wrongdoing by Sanchez. Plaintiff was given an opportunity to amend, but failed to cure the prior defects. Accordingly, demurrer is SUSTAINED without leave to amend.
2ND CAUSE OF ACTION
RETROACTIVE RENT ABATEMENT is not a valid cause of action. It appears that Plaintiff is asserting the remedy of rent abatement for the hazardous and unhealthy conditions that he was subjected to.
The Court construes the 2nd cause of action as a prayer for relief. The Clerk is ordered to strike the “2nd cause of action” by interlineation.
II. Motion to Strike
Defendants Sanchez, Vasquez, and Zakaria move to strike allegations added to the SAC without leave of court.
Although this court did not grant Plaintiff leave to add the new allegations, the court declines to strike the allegations because they relate to Plaintiff’s negligence and habitability claims.
Motion is DENIED.
Dig Deeper
Get Deeper Insights on Court Cases